Rental Appraisal Letter: What’s In It, Who Writes It, How to Get One
A rental appraisal letter is a short written document from a licensed agent stating the weekly rent a property is expected to achieve, with the comparable evidence behind it. Lenders, agencies and third parties ask for one when they need a documented rent estimate rather than a verbal figure. Most agents provide them free.
What it is and why someone asked you for one
A rental appraisal letter is the written, signed version of a rental appraisal. Usually one or two pages. On agency letterhead. Addressed either to you or to whoever asked for it.
You’re probably reading this because someone asked you to produce one and you didn’t know it was a thing. The usual requesters:
- A lender or mortgage broker, assessing how much rental income a property will generate when working out your borrowing capacity on an investment purchase
- An accountant, needing a market rent figure for tax purposes, commonly where a property is rented to a related party and market rent has to be established
- A government agency or program requiring evidence of market rent
- A tribunal or dispute process, though these often want a valuation rather than an agent’s letter
- You, documenting your position before issuing a rent increase
Each wants the same core thing, a rent figure from someone licensed, in writing, with reasoning, but they differ on how much detail and what standing they’ll accept. Which brings us to the most useful thing in this article.
Ask what standard the requester accepts, before you ask for the letter
This is the mistake that costs people a fortnight.
A rental appraisal letter is a licensed estate agent’s opinion of market rent. A valuation is a formal assessment by a certified practising valuer, for a fee, carrying professional standing an appraisal doesn’t have.
Some requesters accept an agent’s letter. Some require a valuer’s report. They rarely say so clearly up front, and the two documents cost very different amounts and take very different amounts of time.
So before you request anything, go back to whoever asked and get an answer to: “Will you accept a rental appraisal letter from a licensed real estate agent, or do you require a valuation from a certified practising valuer?”
Get it in writing if you can. Then order the right document once, instead of the free one first and the paid one three weeks later.
The eight things a rental appraisal letter should contain
If yours is missing several of these, expect it to be questioned.
1. The property address, in full, including unit number. Sounds obvious. Letters get rejected over it.
2. A description of the property. Bedrooms, bathrooms, car spaces, dwelling type, approximate land or floor area, and condition. Enough that a reader who hasn’t seen it understands what’s being appraised.
3. The appraised weekly rent. Usually a range. Some requesters insist on a single figure, ask, and if they do, the letter should still explain the basis.
4. The comparable evidence. The properties the figure is built on: address, bedrooms, bathrooms, parking, condition, the rent achieved, and whether each was leased or merely advertised. This is the part that separates a letter with weight from a letter with a number on it.
5. The basis and assumptions. What condition the property is assumed to be in, whether furnished or unfurnished, and whether the figure assumes any works are completed.
6. The date. Rental markets move. An undated letter is useless, and most requesters won’t accept one more than a few months old.
7. The agent’s name, licence or registration details, and signature. The letter’s value comes from who stands behind it. An unsigned letter from “the leasing team” carries less.
8. Agency details: name, address, phone, and the licensed entity’s name.
Optional but useful: how long comparable properties are taking to lease, and any observation on what would lift the achievable rent.
What yours will not do
Worth being clear, because overstating a letter’s reach is how people get caught out.
It is not a valuation, and won’t be accepted where one is specifically required.
It is not a guarantee. It’s an estimate of what the market should pay, not a promise that it will. No agent can guarantee a rent figure, and one who implies otherwise is overselling.
It is not a legal determination of market rent. If a rent increase is formally challenged, the process that resolves it will consider the evidence before it, your appraisal letter is useful input, not a binding answer.
It is not transferable to a different purpose without checking. A letter prepared for a lender may not satisfy an accountant’s related-party requirement, and vice versa. Tell the agent what it’s for.
The related-party use case, and why accountants ask
One request comes up often enough to deserve its own explanation, because it’s the one people are least prepared for.
If you rent a property to a family member, a related entity, or anyone you’re not dealing with at arm’s length, your accountant may need to establish what market rent for that property is. The arrangement’s tax treatment can depend on whether the rent charged reflects market value, and a documented market rent figure from a licensed agent is the usual way to evidence it.
What that means for the letter you order:
It needs to state market rent, not the rent being charged. Those are different numbers and the whole point is to compare them. Make sure the letter appraises the property on its merits rather than restating the existing arrangement.
The comparable evidence has to be strong. This is a document that may be looked at years later by someone testing whether the figure was reasonable at the time. Six named recent leases is defensible. “Based on comparable properties in the area” is not.
The date is critical. Market rent as at a particular date is the thing being established. A letter without a clear date is close to useless for this purpose.
Ask your accountant whether an agent’s letter is sufficient. For some arrangements it is. For others they’ll want a valuation from a certified practising valuer. This is a question for them, not for us, and the answer determines what you should order.
I’d add one caution. Nothing in this article is tax advice, and the treatment of related-party rental arrangements depends on specifics well beyond a rent figure. Get the advice from your accountant and use the letter as the evidence they ask for, rather than deciding the tax position yourself and then ordering a document to support it.
If the figure comes back lower than you need
It happens, usually when a lender’s borrowing calculation depends on the rental income.
The useless response is to ring three more agents until someone writes a bigger number. That’s how people end up servicing a loan sized against income the property doesn’t produce.
The useful responses: ask what specifically is holding the figure down, because the answer is often one or two fixable items; ask what the property would achieve in better condition and whether the letter can state both figures on a clearly labelled basis; and if the gap is structural rather than cosmetic, take that as information about the purchase rather than a problem with the letter.
A letter that tells you something you didn’t want to hear has done its job.
Why the evidence matters more than the number
There’s a temptation to shop around for the highest figure, especially if a lender is assessing your borrowing capacity against rental income.
Resist it, for a practical reason: an inflated figure that the property then fails to achieve leaves you servicing a loan sized against income you don’t receive. The letter helped you get approved and then hurt you every week for years.
A letter built on six recent leases at named addresses is more valuable than one with a higher number and no evidence, in both directions. It’s more likely to be accepted, and more likely to be true.
When you receive yours, check: how many comparables, and were they leased or advertised? Advertised rents are asking prices. Leased rents are what tenants actually paid. A letter resting entirely on current listings is describing landlord hopes.
How to get one
- Confirm which document the requester accepts: appraisal letter or valuation. First step, every time.
- Approach a licensed agent who manages property in that suburb. Local leasing evidence is the whole substance of the letter.
- Allow an inspection. A letter based on a physical inspection is stronger than a desktop estimate, and some requesters specifically ask whether the property was inspected.
- Say who it’s addressed to and what it’s for. The agent can then include what that reader needs.
- Give the agent the facts. Condition, recent improvements, current rent and lease expiry if tenanted, and any known issues.
- Ask for the comparables to be included, not summarised. “Based on comparable properties in the area” is not evidence.
- Check the date before you submit it. If it’s been sitting in your inbox for four months, ask for a refresh.
Most agencies, including ours, provide rental appraisal letters at no charge.
If you’re preparing for a rent increase
A slightly different use, and the one that’s become more important.
Under Victorian rental law you must give at least 90 days’ notice of a rent increase, the minimum moved from 60 days on 25 November 2025. There’s no legal cap on the amount, but you must give the renter information about how you calculated the increase, and the renter can challenge it if they believe it’s above the market range.
A dated appraisal letter listing the comparable leases your figure rests on is precisely the kind of information that obligation contemplates. It doesn’t make an increase unchallengeable. It does mean that if it’s challenged, you have specific evidence rather than an assertion.
One note on timing. If your property is under a fixed term agreement, you generally can’t increase the rent during the term unless the agreement contains a clause allowing it, and that clause must state how the increase will be calculated. Check the lease before you order anything.
A note on the sale-side documents, because they changed this month
Don’t confuse a rental appraisal letter with the documents on the sale side, which have just been overhauled.
From 1 October 2026, applying to auctions and fixed-date sales from 16 October 2026, the Property Price Statement replaced the Statement of Information in Victoria. Agents must publish the seller’s reserve price at least seven days before an auction or fixed-date sale as a single dollar amount, no “from”, “over” or “+”, and must add the sold price to the Statement within seven days of the sale becoming unconditional, keeping it publicly available for at least 18 months.
Different document, different purpose, different law. But if you’re weighing leasing against selling, those are the rules that now apply to the selling side, and any guide still referring to a Statement of Information predates this month.
What to do next
Work out which document you actually need first. That one question saves more time than anything else here.
If it’s an agent’s rental appraisal letter, ask us and tell us who it’s addressed to and what for. We’ll include the comparable leases with addresses, because a letter without them tends to come back.
And if what you need is a certified practising valuer rather than an agent, we’ll say so. A free letter that gets rejected isn’t a saving.
Frequently asked questions
1. What is a rental appraisal letter? A rental appraisal letter is a short written document from a licensed estate agent, on agency letterhead, stating the weekly rent a property is expected to achieve and setting out the comparable evidence behind that figure. It’s the documented version of a rental appraisal, used when a verbal estimate isn’t enough.
2. What is included in a rental appraisal letter? Eight things: the full property address, a description covering bedrooms, bathrooms, parking and condition, the appraised weekly rent (usually a range), the comparable properties with addresses and whether each was leased or advertised, the basis and assumptions, the date, the agent’s name and licence details with signature, and the agency’s details.
3. Who can write a rental appraisal letter? A licensed estate agent or agent’s representative. The letter’s standing comes from the licence of the person signing it, which is why it should name them and include their registration details. A certified practising valuer writes a valuation instead, which is a different and more formal document.
4. How do I get a rental appraisal letter? First confirm whether the requester accepts an agent’s letter or requires a valuation. Then approach a licensed agent who manages property in that suburb, allow an inspection, tell them who the letter is addressed to and what it’s for, and ask specifically for the comparable properties to be listed rather than summarised.
5. How much does a rental appraisal letter cost? Most agencies, including ours, provide them at no charge, because appraisals are how property managers meet prospective clients. A valuation from a certified practising valuer carries a professional fee. If a requester insists on a valuation, the free letter won’t substitute for it.
6. Is a rental appraisal letter accepted by lenders? Often, but not always, some lenders and some credit processes require a valuation from a certified practising valuer instead. Ask your lender or broker which they accept before you request anything, and get the answer in writing if you can. Ordering the wrong document costs you weeks.
7. Can I use a rental appraisal letter for a visa or government application? It depends entirely on that program’s evidence requirements, and those vary. Some accept a licensed agent’s letter; others specify a valuation or have their own form. Check the published requirements for the specific application rather than assuming, because an agent’s letter and a valuer’s report are not interchangeable.
8. How long is a rental appraisal letter valid? There’s no fixed expiry, but rental markets move and most requesters won’t accept a letter more than a few months old. Check the date before you submit it, and ask for a refreshed letter if time has passed. An undated letter is generally worthless.
9. Can I get a rental appraisal letter for a property I haven’t bought yet? Usually yes, this is a common request from investors assessing a purchase, and lenders often want it. The agent appraises based on the property’s advertised details and comparable leases nearby, though without internal access the figure will be broader. Tell the agent you don’t own it yet so the letter states its basis accurately.
10. What’s the difference between a rental appraisal letter and a valuation? An appraisal letter is a licensed estate agent’s opinion of achievable market rent, normally free, based on local leasing comparables. A valuation is a formal assessment by a certified practising valuer, for a fee, carrying professional standing that an appraisal does not. Courts, tribunals, family law matters and some formal lending decisions require a valuation.
More from One Group Realty
Lyndarum North, Wollert: A Buyer’s Guide to the Estate
Read article →
Rathdowne vs Aurora: Comparing Wollert and Epping’s Two Biggest Estates
Read article →
Subdividing a Block in Melbourne’s North: Cost, Process and Whether Yours Qualifies
Read article →Find out what your property is worth
A free, no-obligation appraisal from an agent who sells in your street.